Words within square brackets ("[]") are my additions or paraphrases. Ellipses in brackets ("[...]" or "[…]") show where I've elided part of a quotation.
Emphasized text is original emphasis; I use the mark element when I want to point something out.
Non-English words are marked up like this.
Anything read before 2018 is unlikely to be added here.
A minimal entry doesn't mean I have nothing to say. It means I haven't yet uploaded the notes for that book.
Score Scale
0: Terrible. No redeeming qualities.
1: Bad. Not saved by scattered sections of higher quality or inventiveness.
2: Poor. Below the bar. Excessive flaws cast a shadow over what may otherwise be enjoyable or have artistic merit. Not worth rereading except for comfort or nostalgia. Recommendable only to those with a strong interest in its topic.
3: Solid. Above the bar. Good parts greatly outweigh any shortcomings. I'm glad to have read it once.
4: Good. Left a unique impression on me, and excels in multiple areas of written composition. Gets prioritized when digitizing my notes and excerpts.
5: Superb. Masterful. Worth reading twice or more.
By the Numbers
185 books
read since 2014, an average of
24.0 a year
over 6 fully recorded years.
Year
Books
2026
22 so far
2025
14
2024
18
2023 (incomplete)
4
2022
19
2021
26
2020
37
2019
30
2018 (incomplete)
6
2017 (incomplete)
7
2016 (incomplete)
1
2015 (incomplete)
0
2014 (incomplete)
1
My to-read list has 204 books on it. At the pace calculated above, reading them all would take 8 years, finishing in 2035. Of course, that assumes I'll never add another book to the list, and we both know that's not true!
For historical content, this book is strong, and it effectively forms a man-on-the-ground narrative from the battles of the Chosin Reservoir campaign of the Korean War. But considered purely on writing quality, it's only decent. For instance, the author has a strange and persistent love of comma-splicing clauses that are nowhere near full sentences. I can accept it as a stylistic quirk, but it makes for uneven reading.
First Hemingway I’ve read in a good long while. The stereotype is that he writes lots of short sentences, but I don’t think that’s true. He likes writes a lot of direct descriptive sentences, but also goes hog wild joining them together into the long run on that are expressive in the way poetry is: dense with imagery, occasionally wandering into philosophical speculation.
I was holding out hope that the ending would not be sad, but it was, and abruptly, viciously so.
I felt a little disappointed that the main plot was ultimately all in Paul Berlin's imagination. Yet there were clues throughout the book, such as in Paul's thoughts to himself while in the observation post, that the soldiers had successfully returned from their search for Cacciato. So I knew ahead of time that in some way they had to have "returned" to Vietnam. I guess I was just holding out hope that all the fantastic events of the book would have really happened.
This book was valuable even though I'd already read Under the Black Flag and The Republic of Pirates. Dolin focuses on piracy's effects on the eastern seaboard of colonial-era America, which the other books only covered in passing as necessary.
For instance, from The Republic of Pirates I knew the basic outline of Henry Avery's attack on Muslim treasure fleets off the coast of India, but I never knew that the Mughal Empire's outcry over that attack, transmitted to the British East India Company and from there to the Crown, directly led to an Act of Parliament which materially contributed to the decline of piracy in its Golden Age. I also didn't know that there was a thriving pirate base in Madagascar involved in both the slave trade and the transport of pirates to and from the New World.
A History of Warfare [recommended by SSC user Del Cotter: it might as well be called "War Systems Very Different From Ours". It takes Clausewitz's aphorism, and, noting that it doesn't really describe war as many societies have waged it, takes a tour of military cultures in history that were not just different, but based on a different understanding of what war is.]
Computers as Theatre (Brenda Laurel)
Hamlet on the Holodeck
Super Forecasting
The House Without Windows (Barbara Newhall Follett)
Can't Pay? Won't Pay!
The Decadent Society (Ross Douthat)
Kiln People
Tall Trees Tough Men (Robert Everding Pike)
The Mom Test (Rob Fitzpatrick) [supposed to be stupendous for product development]
The Dream Machine - M. Mitchell Waldrop (:vote 2) (available through https://press.stripe.com)
Turing's Cathedral
A Chinese Life - Li Kunwu [graphic novel]
Confessions of an Economic Hitman
A Study in Words - C. S. Lewis
The Conquest of the Useless (Werner Herzog - about filming Fitzcarraldo)
Movies/films and shows: Dr. Zhivago, Lawrence of Arabia, Emitai [by Ousmane Sembene], Jeeves and Wooster (1990-1993 Fry and Laurie show), Chinatown, Adaptation, Big Sleep, Citizen Kane, Fitzcarraldo, Twentieth Century Women, Vertigo, Drinking Buddies [2013], Orange County [2002], Make Way for Tomorrow [1937], Waterloo Bridge [1941 version], 三峡好人, Beijing Bicycle, Gunga Din, My Dinner with Andre, The Betrayal (rules vs. moral codes; amazing sword fight), My Man Godfrey, Cleo from 5 to 7, Scenes from a Marriage, Ashes and Diamonds (end-of-WWII Poland; made in 1950s), movies by Kieslowski, Vertigo, Song of the Sea (2014), Waves (:via LR), Forbidden Planet, Metropolis, Jodorowsky's Dune, Michael Collins, Endless Summer, Margin Call, Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World, To Live and Die in LA
This is Orson Welles
52 Ways of Looking at a Poem
Jesus the Jew (Geza Vermes)
Mindstorms (Simon Papert)
The Faithful Executioner: Life and Death, Honor and Shame in the Turbulent Sixteenth Century (Joel F. Harrington)
撒哈拉的故事 (三毛)
Heart of Darkness
Behave (Robert M Sapolsky)
Three Men of the Beagle (Richard Lee Marks)
Diplomacy (Kissinger)
Haunted by Chaos (Sulmaan Wasif Khan)
The Tragedy of Liberation / Mao's Great Famine / The Cultural Revolution (Frank Dikötter) [trilogy]
Free to Choose (Milton Friedman) [available as free video series]
Platform (Michel Houellebecq) 3/5.
The Once and Future King
City of God (Paulo Lins)
The Way Things Work (David Macaulay)
Spirit Level Delusion
The Futurological Congress
Days of Rage
Turtle Geometry (Harold Abelson)
(:vote 2) Draft No. 4 (John McPhee)
On Paradise Drive (David Brooks)
唐诗三百首 / Three Hundred Tang Poems
Black Book of Communism
Interviewing Leather
Defending the Undefendable
Never Split the Difference
Science and Civilization in China (Joseph Needham) [available as online scans]